The real Superman’s resurrection is just as stupid. See, apparently, due to his Kryptonian physiology, the laws of human death
don’t apply to himââ¬Â¦after he seemed to die (really, it was just some kind of Kryptonian healing trance or something), his faithful robot
(voiced by Tom Kenny, but mercifully restrained) retrieves his cooling corpse and reanimates him. See, Superman can’t really die. The
point of the ââ¬ÅDeath of Supermanââ¬? storyline was to prove that despite Big Blue’s powers, he is mortal. Here, he isn’t, which
completely rob the story of any real impact. In the comics, there were very unique circumstances that allowed the Eradicator to revive
Superman (and in fact, the Eradicator warns him not to count on it working again). In this version of the story, death is just another
speed bump. Next time he croaks, his faithful robot will come get him and he’ll respawn three days later just like that Jesus guy.
While the real Superman (given the hippie long hair he got in the comics when he returned from the grave) is lifting weights and
soaking up the sun, Dark Supes trepans himself with his heat vision to remove a capsule of Kryptonite from his brain. Seems Luthor
put it there to control him. So, apparently, in addition to trying to cure cancer, Superman can do brain surgery. Okay, so the Justice Lord Superman lobotomized people this way. I still find it mildly disturbing that he’s able to bore a hole in his own head.
Back at Really Fucking Evil Tower, Lois (who has gathered up Jimmy from his new job at a tabloid – apparently,
Superman’s death made him decide to sell out) confronts Luthor. After he tries to seduce her (yes, they resurrected the old ââ¬ÅLex as
Clark’s rival for Lois’s affectionsââ¬? idea), Lois drugs him by sticking a huge needle in his neck, then proceeds to ransack his office. If Lex
Luthor’s such a fucking genius, why doesn’t he have something as simple as a password on his computer to protect the location of his
Evil Secret Lab?
Ever since Super Friends went off the air, writers have been working hard to make Lex Luthor seem like an intelligent
villain. This movie has undone 20 years of progress and made him into a blustering idiot again.
In the basement (or wherever Lex keeps his Evil Secret Lab), Lois discovers hundreds of Superman clones in vats, and the first
clone shows up to tell Luthor to piss off. Lex, seeing his creation go rogue and being really fucking evil, yanks out his
handy-dandy remote, dramatically presses the buttonââ¬Â¦and nothing happens. To his credit, Lex handles it with the usual Luthor aplomb. He doesn’t lose his cool and just mutters, ââ¬ÅOh, hell.ââ¬?
This might be better if we hadn’t seen the same thing on screen hundreds of times (Luthor’s reaction to it is priceless, though).
Since when has a remote-controlled implant designed to kill someone if they get out of line ever worked? It’s so clichéd that it should
be on the Evil Overlord List. When I set out to conquer the world, I’m never going to implant a capsule of poison or a bomb or anything
else in a minion’s head to control them, because they always find a way to disable it, and I’m not going to figure it out until I press the
damn button and expect them to keel over. It’s just embarrassing.
Eventually, the real Supes stops watching TV long enough to go back to Metropolis to take on his doppelganger (who has by now
killed all of the other duplicates by boiling them in their tubes). There’s another brawl in the middle of Metropolis, of course. You’d
think by now the city’s citizens would get sick of rebuilding after all these super-rampages.
It’s like Tokyo and Godzilla – no matter how
many buildings get destroyed, the people never just say, “Fuck this.” and move to Kyoto or Kansas City or some other place not subject
to periodic kaiju attacks.
Before the two Supermen go at it, they spout awful speeches at each other. Adam Baldwin delivers these lines like he’s reading
them off of a cereal box. Baldwin is talented and has done good voiceover in the past. The voice director is, as usual for animated DC
work, Andrea Romano. She usually gets the best out of everyone, but here she’s failed. These speeches sound like they knew how
awful the writing was and simply gave up. In my head I can see Adam Baldwin in the recording booth turning to Romano and saying,
“Aw, hell, can’t you just use the first take? Lemme take ya out for a beer.” (For some reason, in my head I always see Adam Baldwin
taking people out for a beer. He seems like the kind of nice guy who buys everyone a drink.)
During the fight, Lois is dumb enough to stand in the middle of the street while glass rains down. Of course, this is the same
woman who went 50-some years without realizing that Clark is the same guy without his glasses. She’s not real bright.
After Superman’s evil twin is beaten, everyone immediately proclaims the real one to be their savior. Is everyone in Metropolis as
dumb as Lois? Just because he beat the rogue Superman (And just how do they know the ‘evil’ one’s a clone? They fucking
don’t.) doesn’t make him the real thing. This is a case of Comic Book Logic. Normally, I’d forgive this, but on top of the other crap
this movie has already subjected me to, I’m not going to. I’m in a vindictive mood.
Of the disc’s special features, the most notable is the documentary about the “Death of Superman” storyline in the comics. Why
does it have a documentary on the comics storyline when the movie is almost completely different and doesn’t even include any of the
four Supermen?
Overall, this movie isn’t as bad as, say, Battlefield Earth. But then, nothing – absolutely nothing – is as bad as Battlefield
Earth. It’s maybe not even the level of sheer awfulness of the Garfield movies. But Lord knows it isn’t good. It manages to
hit on nearly every comic book cliché, and doesn’t even put a unique spin on any of them. The Chef gives it two out of five undead hot
dogs.