There are times when I really wonder why I sit down to write these reviews. There are other times when I really wonder why I watch stuff just because I kinda liked something that was part of the same series, even if it’s not really the same series and isn’t that great. Stargate: Continuum triggers both of those reactions.
For those not in the know, after SG-1 ended, the producers decided to move on to making direct-to-DVD movies and letting Atlantis carry the torch of the Stargate franchise on television (and, to be fair, Atlantis has been a much better series than the SG-1 episodes produced at the same time). The first, The Ark of Truth (which I’ll get to eventually in this series), wrapped up the Ori story arc from the last two seasons of SG-1 and gave it the kind of finale it should have had in the first place (why they didn’t just turn that story into the season finale instead of making the tedious crap of “Unending”, the last episode, I’ll never know). I also like to use parenthesis a lot.
Anyway, Continuum is a time travel/alternate timeline episode, something the Stargate franchise has never done particularly well. Of course, keep in mind that even Star Trek rarely managed to pull off this theme successfully. As it stands, this is a mash-up of “There But For the Grace of God” and “Moebius”, combining the “nightmare invasion” scenario with the “we’ve got to go back in time and fix it, but the government won’t let us” theme. Mind you, after a series has been running this long, we’re bound to see some elements repeat themselves (and really, there isn’t much new in “regular” science fiction anyway). This, however, is a stock-standard “bad dream” episode stretched out over an excruciatingly dull hour and a half, that does nothing but serve to prove to us that Baal is really and truly dead and they mean it this time, dammit.
Whoops. Guess I should’ve put a spoiler warning or something there. But come on – he’s not really dead, and we know it. If they ever produce more movies from this series, he’ll be back.
See, back around season 8 or so of SG-1, the Goa’uld (the Big Bads of the show) pretty well got their asses kicked by a primitive tribe of hyoomans from a miserable backwater dirtball called Earth. The last of the System Lords with any power left, Baal (charismatically played by Cliff Simon), cloned himself and his human host. I suspect the writers did it because they enjoyed Cliffy’s smugly superior acting as much as the audience does. This horde of clones unlike anything seen since Spider-Man got stuck in the copy machine gave the writers one hell of an opportunity to play with: they got to bump off Baal in every single episode he showed up in, and yet still have him around when they needed him again to provide a bad guy who wasn’t the Ori.
Supposedly, the last of Baal’s clones (or maybe the original – you can’t really tell them apart) died in the last season of the series, but we all knew it was a ruse. Continuum starts off with SG-1 traveling to…somewhere to attend a ceremony to rip Baal out of his host’s skull. Firstly, keep in mind that this is the “new” SG-1, with Mitchell instead of O’Neill and with Vala (Claudia Black) thrown in for…whatever the hell Vala’s job is. Annoying the audience, I think. She’s not really good for anything else. If SG-1 was a D&D adventuring party, she’d be the bard. But on the upside and almost making up for having Claudia Black around, they’ve got the now-General O’Neill along, who finally got off of his ass in Washington to do something useful (my guess is that the DVD sales of MacGuyver were down and Richard Dean Anderson needed a car payment).
As a side note, I really fucking hate Claudia Black. She annoys me. She annoys me as no one outside of Paula Deen or that fast-talking bastard in the Micro Machines commercials does. Over the years Vala has been appearing, she hasn’t grown on me. I hate her now more than I ever have. When I say I hate her, I want you to grasp my full meaning. I’d rather have Jonas Quinn around than her. I have no idea how Farscape fans stand her.
Anyway, the Tok’ra (the good-guy symbiotes who kinda like the Mirror Universe versions of the Goa’uld, but without being from another universe) are ready to vacuum Baal out of his human host. Why they’re concerned for this particular human host when they’ve bumped off dozens just like him in deflating the various Baals (these are the jokes, folks) is beyond me. Maybe it’s some kind of sick token effort at saying “Hey, we’re the good guys!”. The poor guy’s been possessed by a power-crazed alien snake for the last couple thousand years, and has stood by and watched his body commit thousands of atrocities from massacring human slaves to not paying his taxes (Baal spent a fair bit of time on Earth). Frankly, just putting him out of his misery would be cheaper than paying for the years of psychotherapy he’s gonna need to get over that.
As they’re about to sluck Baal out of his host, people start vanishing, starting with Vala. If Baal had stopped at making Vala disappear from history, I would have been glad to let him rule the universe out of gratitude. Then other people start going missing, and it’s apparent something’s badly wrong. Carter, Mitchell, and Jackson make a run for the gate and end up coming out on an Earth where the Stargate wasn’t found. Oh, and they’re freezing their asses off in the Arctic.
As you can probably guess, at some point Baal (or another clone of Baal – whichever it is) has traveled back in time and changed history. Why history doesn’t change all at once is beyond me, but that’s the way it is. And now Carter, Mitchell, and Jackson have to convince a government that (once again) doesn’t really believe things out there in the galaxy are as bad as they are to let them use the Stargate to fix things.
I’m going to come right out and say I’m not fond of the mechanism common to time travel in Stargate; it involves a whole lot of skeevy physics and violating wormholes in ways not see outside of Stephen Hawking’s porn collection. And in the show’s universe, you can indeed travel through time, cause a paradox, and get away with it. At least they’ve sort of got a set of rules governing how things work, unlike Star Trek.
Within the alternate timeline, there are some nice moments reminiscent of the “old” SG-1, when humanity doesn’t have flashy alientech ray guns (but not Reagans) and spaceships, and they’re fighting a vastly superior foe. However, those times are (to us fans) long in the past, and it feels just plain wrong to see everything corrupted and reset like that. Maybe that’s what the producers were going for.
The Goa’uld attack on Earth has some nice cameos of characters we haven’t seen in years (such as Peter Williams returning as Apophis for the umpteenth time since his character’s death), some of them twisted in interesting ways. However, by now we’ve seen a couple dozen alternate timeline/universe versions of Apophis, and it’s getting old. At least this one doesn’t have a fucking goatee.
It’s also worth noting that, as is dreadfully usual in these kind of alternate timeline/”bad dream” stories, the writers indulge in bumping off nearly all of the main characters, because everything’s going to be reset in the end and they’ll be fine. Why is it that every story in every franchise that deals with this theme has to turn it into a slaughterfest? Honestly, guys, at least fucking try to be original.
Really, this movie is only for fanboys of the series, and only the most hardcore ones at that. For anyone else, Stargate: Continuum is really just an exercise in tedium. The plot is dull and predictable (and has been overdone), Claudia Black is annoying, and this movie does nothing that couldn’t have been accomplished in a one-hour show. It does get extra points for not having Mitchell end up being his own grandfather, though.